| 
   
   
     
       
         | 
       
        
      
      Lake Renegade 
      pilot report 
      
      
                              
                              Simon Broek 
            
            
                              
                              I have said it many times before. I just have a 
                              weakness for things and machines that breathe 
                              utility, be it a paper clip, a Landrover or an 
                              aircraft. Great sky bound examples of  the 
                              ‘form follows function’ philosophy are the Pilatus 
                              PC-6 Porter, the De-Havilland DHC-2 Beaver and 
                              DHC-6 Twin-Otter, The 180 and 185 from Cessna and 
                              the Helio Courier. All of them are aircraft found 
                              in the most remote regions of the world where they 
                              are used as workhorses on a variety of missions. 
                              Unless extensively modified however all these 
                              aircraft rely on some kind of firm runway for 
                              take-offs and landings. In today’s market there is 
                              one marked exception, the Renegade family of 
                              aircraft from Lake. 
                               
                              History 
                               
                              Lake Aircraft with bases in Laconia New Hampshire, 
                              Kissimmee Florida and Stanford Maine, is currently 
                              the world’s only manufacturer of certified single 
                              engine flying boats. Although largely unknown by 
                              the public, the people at Lake Aircraft have been 
                              building flying boats for over half a century. It 
                              all began in 1946 when David B. Thurston and 
                              Herbert P Lindbad founded the Colonial Aircraft 
                              Corporation. Previously the two talented engineers 
                              had been working for the Grumman Aircraft Company 
                              on the successful Grumman Goose and Widgeon 
                              amphibian twins. They also worked on a 
                              lesser-known aircraft, the G-65 tadpole, that flew 
                              for the first time in 1944.  
                                
                              
                              The 
                              Tadpole was a single engine two-seater flying boat 
                              that was geared towards the private and business 
                              market. Before proving it’s self to the top 
                              executives at Grumman the Tadpole program got 
                              scrapped, much to the dismay of  Thurston and 
                              Herbert. They were both a firm believer of a 
                              marker for such an aircraft and driven by this 
                              belief they left Grumman and set up shop for 
                              themselves. 
                                
                              
                              Their 
                              first aircraft was the three-seater Colonial 
                              Skimmer. This aircraft with a now characteristic 
                              pylon mounted engine on top of the fuselage, first 
                              flew in the summer of 1948. Colonial eventually 
                              built 42 Skimmers of which 18 were Skimmer two’s 
                              which had four seats. 
                               
                              Because of slow sales, Colonial had to close their 
                              doors in 1959, but haunted by his dream Herbert 
                              Lindbad soon after founded a new company under the 
                              name Lake Aircraft Corporation. 
                               
                              Lindbad almost redesigned the Skimmer from the 
                              ground up, before re-introducing it as the LA-4 in 
                              1959. Three years later, Lake was bought by 
                              Consolidated Aeronautics Inc. who split Lake up in 
                              two divisions. On one side was Aerofab Inc, that 
                              was to built the aircraft in Stanford, Maine and 
                              on the other side was the Lake Aircraft Division 
                              that was to take care of the sale and service of 
                              the aircraft. 
                               
                              In 1979, Armand Rivard bought both divisions and 
                              has been building Lakes of various shapes and 
                              sizes ever since. 
                               
                              Models 
                               
                              As said, Lake started building the LA-4 back in 
                              the 60’s. This was a four-seater aircraft powered 
                              by a 180 HP pylon mounted engine. A decent 
                              performer on land and in the air, the LA-4 was 
                              somewhat of a disappointment on the water.  
                              When operated off water, the LA-4 was downgraded 
                              to a two seat aircraft. The 180 ponies on the roof 
                              just could not lift anything more then that. 
                                
                              
                              This 
                              prompted Lake to install a 200 HP Lycoming 
                              instead, turning the LA-4 into the LA-4-200. From 
                              this moment the designation was complemented by 
                              the name ‘Buccaneer’. During the early eighties 
                              the buccaneer was replaced by the LA-200EP (Extra 
                              Power). To claim the extra power the EP received a 
                              lengthened propeller shaft and a much-improved 
                              cowling, resulting in less drag and more thrust. 
                              Some EP’s also received a reversible propeller, 
                              greatly improving the slow speed handling on 
                              water. These now rare aircraft,  received the 
                              designation LA-200EPR. 
                               
                              In 1982 Lake took a huge step forward with the 
                              introduction of the greatly improved LA-250 
                              Renegade. The Renegade still bares the family 
                              features of the earlier models but is enlarged to 
                              accommodate 6 adults quite comfortably. Up in the 
                              pylon the Four Cylinder IO-360 made way for a six 
                              Cylinder IO-540 that produces 250 HP. Besides a 
                              jump in useful load, the Renegade offers much 
                              improved water handling, through it’s 
                              substantially longer deep V hull. To feed the 
                              thirstier Lycoming, the fuel capacity was 
                              increased to a maximum of 90 gallons. Besides 
                              these obvious modifications, many more detail 
                              improvements found their way into the new 
                              Renegade.  
                              
                                
                              
                              In 1987 
                              a Turbo charged variant of the Renegade, the 
                              LA-270T Turbo Renegade was introduced to 
                              accommodate altitude hungry aviators. 
                               
                              Although the Renegade is universally accepted as a 
                              very capable aircraft, Lake hasn’t been sitting 
                              still in recent years. The Renegades are slowly 
                              being replaced on the production line by Seafuries. 
                              As the name implies, the Seafury is especially 
                              geared to salt water operations. The biggest 
                              difference between it and the Renegade is the 
                              generous use of space age ceramic corrosion 
                              proofing techniques to protect the Seafury’s 
                              construction in the harshest of environments. The 
                              Seafury comes in both the 250 normally aspirated 
                              and the 270 HP turbocharged versions. 
                               
                              Military brethren 
                              
                                
                              
                               
                              Last but not least there are the two military 
                              versions of the Renegade family. The most potent 
                              is the Seawolfe. Blessed with a higher gross 
                              weight, a 290 HP turbocharged engine, and six 
                              standard Nato hard points under the wing, the 
                              Seawolf can be adapted for a multitude of 
                              missions. The most frequent use of this wolf in 
                              sheep’s clothes, is that of Marine Patrol and 
                              Search and Rescue With it’s capacity to carry 
                              rockets, guns, night vision equipment, radar and 
                              infra red and visible spectrum camera’s however, 
                              the sky is the limit. 
                                
                              
                              For 
                              those who want the higher gross weight but don’t 
                              need all the bells and whistles of the Seawolfe, 
                              there is the Ranger. This is basically a beefed up 
                              Seafury with a 290 HP engine. 
                               
                              Laconia   
                               
                              On one beautiful late summer day, I drive my 
                              rental car into Laconia, New Hampshire. On a 
                              corner, next to the local high school that looks 
                              like the set of a Hollywood saga on small-town 
                              USA, I drop a quarter in a payphone and call Bruce 
                              Rivard, son of Armand and Vice-President of the 
                              Lake Aircraft Company. He gives me directions to 
                              the airport and will meet me there in 20 minutes. 
                              Arriving at the airport, the Lake Aircraft hangar 
                              would be a rather obscure building was it not for 
                              a ring of ‘experienced’ Buccaneers and Renegades 
                              that surround it. It’s an other 10 minutes before 
                              Bruce arrives in a just as ‘mature’ Volkswagen 
                              Rabbit, sporting shorts a t-shirt and loafers. 
                              Like the aircraft they build, the Revards are 
                              practical people. He greets me with a warm 
                              “Welcome to the flying boat capital of the world” 
                              and a firm handshake. We spend about fifteen 
                              minutes walking around the premises and chatting 
                              about Lake’s history, the aircraft they build now 
                              and what the future holds for this last outpost of 
                              ‘wet feet’ aviation. 
                                
            
                              
                                
            
                              
                              
                               The 
                              aircraft outside, that all look the part of hard 
                              working and hard playing machines, are contrasted 
                              by a brand new Seawolf and a totally restored EP 
                              inside that both look and smell brand new. Bruce 
                              knows that these two beautiful aircraft will look 
                              just as ‘used’ as the ones outside before the year 
                              is over. “Lake aircraft are built for a serious 
                              pounding and that is exactly what the new owners 
                              of these aircraft will do with them. They are 
                              built for the rough and soon will look the part.” 
                              Bruce says. He doesn’t mind though, because a 
                              great deal of his business is the maintenance and 
                              repair of used Lakes form all over the country and 
                              in fact the world. Owners love coming back to the 
                              birthplace of their aircraft as well. Because the 
                              technicians have been around forever, and all 
                              necessary parts are only footsteps from the work 
                              floor, the cost is kept down and the turn around 
                              times for repairs and inspections are minimised. 
                               
                                
                              
                               
                              The impressive Seawolfe is going through its last 
                              checks before being delivered to an anonymous 
                              client in the Far East. Anonymous? My querying 
                              look is answered with a smile from Bruce and a 
                              cheerful, “Don’t worry, we only sell Seawolfes to 
                              the ‘good guys’. The bad guys only get the Ranger, 
                              that can’t take rockets and guns.”   
                               
                              To my question; why they stopped building the four 
                              seater, Bruce answers; “ It costs about as much to 
                              build a Renegade as it does a Buccaneer and for 
                              the same money you get much more aircraft. There 
                              just was no demand for the Buccaneer anymore.” 
                              Lake is now seeing the same thing happening with 
                              the Seafury. Despite the $40,000 higher price tag 
                              for all the fancy corrosion proofing, most people 
                              now want to get a Seafury instead of a Renegade. 
                               
                               
                              Out to fly and float   
                                
                              
                               
                              To the side of the hangar, towards the runway, 
                              awaits my magic carpet for the afternoon. N8435A 
                              is a customer’s LA-270T that the Rivards lease 
                              back for the occasional demonstration and training 
                              flight. With around 600 hours total time she is an 
                              average example of a turbocharged Renegade. Her 
                              exterior shows a few scuffmarks from 
                              overenthusiastic encounters with docks and ramps 
                              but in all she looks pretty clean. It is soon 
                              apparent that the aircraft is pretty low slung and 
                              that eye level for the pilot is about waist high 
                              for an average standing person. This makes for an 
                              interesting perspective for the novice Lake 
                              driver, both on land and on water. Everything on 
                              the aircraft breathes functionality. No frills 
                              bells and whistles can be found anywhere, just 
                              straight utility. Ingress to the aircraft’s 
                              interior is made quite easy by the generous 
                              folding canopies up front and the huge ‘cargo 
                              door’ to the right hand side. Opening both the 
                              right hand canopy and door reveals a huge entry 
                              for long and bulky items such as stretchers golf 
                              bags or ski’s. Behind the pilot seats, a 10 feet 
                              flat floor area can be revealed by simply removing 
                              the passenger seats. 
                                
                              
                              The 
                              front row passengers have ample room and a grand 
                              unobstructed view through the large windows. That 
                              is contrasted by the ‘cheap seats’ in the back of 
                              the cabin that lack legroom and windows. Although 
                              there is a side window modification available for 
                              the Renegade, Bruce admits that most people use 
                              the aft seating area for extra baggage space and 
                              therefore don’t bother with it. 
                               
                              Just as we are completing the pre-flight of three 
                              five Alpha, a minibus stops and a handsome young 
                              man and pretty girl get out. It is Bruce’s son Ian 
                              and one of his classmates he seems eager to 
                              impress. A few moments later the two teens clime 
                              over the transom into the back seats, while I take 
                              a seat next to Bruce up front. The cargo door is 
                              closed, but we keep one of the canopies wide open. 
                              Since the aft facing propeller does not generate 
                              any slipstream in the cockpit we can enjoy the 
                              fresh air while taxiing to the active for take 
                              off. The nose gear is free turning so we steer on 
                              the ground by occasionally tapping the brakes. 
                              This is easy enough in the calm afternoon air, but 
                              can be a challenge when facing a stiff crosswind. 
                              Thanks to the aft mounted wing, and the sloped 
                              nose the view from the pilot seat is absolutely 
                              unique. It is therefore not surprising that Lake’s 
                              are slowly starting to dominate the market of 
                              marine and law enforcement observation aircraft.
                               
                              
                              As an 
                              aerial photographer, I can certainly appreciate 
                              that side of the Lake’s inner beauty.   
                               
                              For a novice, the overhead engine controls are a 
                              bit of a novelty for small aircraft. Having flown 
                              the De Havilland Twin-Otter however, I feel right 
                              at home. After some last checks and the careful 
                              latching of the canopy we are free to push the 
                              throttle all the way forward. The Turbocharged 
                              Lycoming is fitted with an automatic waist gate to 
                              control the maximum manifold pressure, so we don’t 
                              have to tweak the throttle until we reduce the 
                              power for the climb. Noise is typical for a light 
                              aircraft, but perhaps a little less intrusive in 
                              the cockpit because of the engine’s aft position. 
                              The take-off run took no more then 6 or 700 feet 
                              and after tucking the wheels into the wings and 
                              nose the climb rate settles on a hefty 1100 feet. 
                              Not bad for a 20 feet cabin cruiser… The gears, 
                              like the flaps and elevator trim are hydraulically 
                              controlled. Pressure is generated by an electrical 
                              pump and is stabilized by an accumulator. In case 
                              of a failure of the electrical pump, a hand pump 
                              is available to charge the accumulator. 
                               
                                
                              
                               
                              Once airborne and trimmed for straight and level 
                              flight, the flight controls feel firm and 
                              surprisingly well coordinated. As expected, the 
                              Renegade is not a ballerina, but still 
                              surprisingly nimble when coached firmly. In the 
                              smooth air above lake Winnipesaukee, the Renegade 
                              holds her course admirably when the yoke is 
                              released. 
         
                              As in any amphibian aircraft, landings are to be 
                              well-rehearsed exercises in procedures. Whereas a 
                              wheel up landing on firm ground will do little 
                              more to a Lake then scratch the paint off the 
                              keel, a wheel down landing on water could spell 
                              instant disaster. The main gears are easily 
                              monitored from the cockpit, while the nose wheel 
                              can be checked in a little mirror mounted to the 
                              left hand pontoon. As experienced as he is, Bruce 
                              says the amphibian pilot chant out loud; “Water 
                              landing, gear is up”, while visually checking the 
                              gear handle, all three gears, and last but not 
                              least the blue light on the console. Bruce retards 
                              the power to bleed off some speed and selects the 
                              flaps to down. This is a ‘no brainer’, since the 
                              flaps have only two positions. Up for flight and 
                              down for take-off and landing. We can now see how 
                              much drag the Lake can generate. Even without the 
                              gear down the waters below fill both canopies 
                              while the speed is nice and stabilized. 
                               
                              
                              That 
                              steep approach can sure come in handy when 
                              operating from small bodies of water in 
                              mountainous terrain. Just above the water Bruce 
                              pulls straight to bleed off the speed before 
                              touching the wave tops in a level attitude. Once 
                              in the water an ungodly noise erupts from metal 
                              pounding on rock hard water. This is why Lakes 
                              must be built like a brick (you know what) house. 
                              The wild ride only lasts a few seconds though as 
                              the Lake settles trough the waves and continues 
                              leisurely to the shore. We head for a ramp at what 
                              use to be Armand Rivard’s house, a beautiful 
                              contemporary wooden building with large decks 
                              overlooking the shore.   
                               
                              Before reaching the ramp, Bruce lowers the gear 
                              and when convinced he is over firm ground he 
                              hammers the throttle forward to keep his momentum 
                              up the steep ramp. The roar of the engine brings 
                              people from surrounding houses to their decks to 
                              watch the spectacle. To my relief their raised 
                              hands are not bald in fists but are waiving 
                              friendly. This kind of tolerance can be an example 
                              for tight-butted Europeans who mow their lawns 
                              every Saturday with annoying power mowers, but 
                              frown at every light aircraft that comes overhead. 
                               
                              The girl is gallantly helped out of the back and 
                              continues to walk up the road to her house on the 
                              hill. The smile and the friendly wave back tells 
                              me that Ian’s mission is a success. It’s hard not 
                              to be impressed by a ride home and a drop-off on 
                              the lakefront by a Lake Renegade…   
                               
                              I stay on shore to make a couple of pictures as 
                              Bruce and Ian take to the water for a couple of 
                              low fly by’s and ‘splash and goes’. Ten minutes 
                              later they are back to pick me up and we head 
                              trough the air for a small beach around the corner 
                              from Bruce’s waterfront home. His wife Katy and 
                              younger son Brandon are awaiting us with a small 
                              speedboat for some more pictures. Without lowering 
                              the gear Bruce runs the Lake op on the beach just 
                              like a boat and allows us to get out without 
                              getting our feet wet. After introductions, I take 
                              to the water in the speedboat with Katie and Ian, 
                              while Bruce and Brandon get back in the Renegade. 
                              Out on the water Bruce plays with the Renegade as 
                              if it is a dragon fly dashing over the surface. My 
                              Gyro Stabilizer is zooming happily and my motor 
                              drive is running hot shooting roll after roll of 
                              film in the beautiful sunset.   
                               
                              When the film is all shot, we return to the 
                              Rivard’s family jetty at the bottom of the garden. 
                              Before getting my gear packed and up the stairs, 
                              Bruce and Brandon are back from the airport. 
                               
                               
                              After one of the most incredible days in my flying 
                              career, my luck is still not over. Armand, who 
                              lives in Florida most of the year, is in town and 
                              he and Bruce invite me to dinner at the local hot 
                              spot. There the evening fades with good food and 
                              great conversation. What did we talk about? What 
                              do you think. Lake aircraft and the incredible 
                              adventures they open up.   
                              The Lake Renegade is in a league of it’s own and 
                              therefore hard to measure against other aircraft. 
                              What surprised me most of all was that as a flying 
                              machine it hold it’s own in the company of 
                              landlocked machines such as Cessna’s 206 and Piper 
                              Cherokee Six.  
          
                              As a boat, well having seen the Renegade in action 
                              at the hands of a master, leads me to believe that 
                              Bayliners are toys for kids. Combining the two 
                              worlds in just one machine makes it simply 
                              irresistible to adventure seeking aeronautical 
                              buffs like me. The only thing missing for me to 
                              get a Renegade of my own is a bank account to mach 
                              my desire. One day though, one day… 
   | 
        
      
    
    |